The release of the findings of the Competition Commission’s Health Market Inquiry (HMI) and consequent drive to uniform tariffs, the imminent National Health Insurance (NHI) rollout, continued consolidation of medical aids, and the inextricable rise of medical inflation could culminate in a perfect storm for the healthcare sector.
With National Health Insurance (NHI), the Health Market Inquiry (HMI), blockchain, venture capital, innovation in health financing, health delivery, and medical devices, what will SA’s new healthcare landscape look like? This was the focus at the Healthcare Industry Updates and Innovation Conference held in Johannesburg recently.
HEALTH DEPT ON NHI & THE HMI
In his keynote address, deputy director general of NHI at the National Department of Health, Dr Anban Pillay, took a closer look at NHI and the Health Market Inquiry. “In SA we’re reforming the structure of the health system, we’re reforming the way services are delivered, the way healthcare providers are paid, the way procurement and purchasing happens,” said Dr Pillay. “The Minister (Dr Aaron Motsoaledi) likes to say this is a massive reorganisation of the public and private healthcare system.”
“Having divided the SA population into five sectors based on income, employment, and medical scheme coverage, “in the rollout of NHI we will start with the most vulnerable groups and progressively include sectors,” said Dr Pillay.
Attendees hoping for an update of what NHI is going to cost SA were left disappointed. Despite the fact the projected R256bn in the 2025 figure provided in the 2017 white paper is a 2010 figure, which is badly outdated and entirely unrealistic – and even Dr Motsoaledi has admitted government ‘made a mistake with the figures’ – when it came to addressing the cost of NHI and where the money will come from, Dr Pillay deferred to the problematic R256bn budget and discussed alternative tax scenarios to fund a R71.9bn (2010 prices) NHI funding shortfall.
Dr Pillay faced a gruelling round of questions covering everything from how NHI is possible when pilot sites have performed so dismally, and how illegal immigrants’ medical costs will be paid, to contradictions between HPCSA rules and governments’ new policies, and the problem of staff shortages, lack of equipment, and the questionable state of many facilities in the public healthcare sector.
Independent healthcare consultant and board member at Momentum Health, Dr Elton Dorkin, chaired a fervent panel discussion on the new healthcare landscape following NHI and HMI between
Dr Anchen Laubscher (Netcare Limited medical director), Adam Pyle (Life Healthcare SA CEO), Dr Ryan Noach (Discovery Health deputy CEO), Dr Katlego Mothudi (Board of Healthcare Funders of Southern Africa managing director), and Dr Ntuthuko Bhengu (HMI panel member and health sector specialist), none of whom held any punches.
PHARMA & UNIVERSAL HEALTHCARE (UHC)
Addressing concerns over NHI in the pharma-care landscape Stavros Nicolaou (Aspen Pharmacare senior executive, strategic trade development) was adamant, “UHC has to happen, but we have to get the balance right. There are risks to business models, but you just need to accommodate access and coverage on the one end, and then sustainability of economy and business models on the other.”
While echoing Nicolaou’s sentiments on the need for UHC, Dr Mandisa Maholwana (Nelson Mandela Children’s Hospital CEO) cautioned she didn’t believe it could be achieved by doing away with either private or public healthcare. “We need both to succeed.”
Dr Maholwana raised further concerns about blanket decisions when it comes to things like fixing prices. “Different provinces have different needs. Is it really best to fix prices across all provinces? If a province has a higher demand for a certain drug surely they should get a cheaper price?” She also stressed that UHC should not come at the expense of smaller pharmaceutical companies. “We need to come together to find a way forward without compromising values.”
When it comes to pharmaceuticals, Gavin Bauer (Sanofi SA head of market access) believes there is a lot of opportunity in NHI.
“Government has been quite accommodating towards our industry and companies. With regard to pricing of drugs, it’s going to be an evolution not a revolution.” He did however caution the importance of prices not being forced so low that it’s no longer financially viable to make as this will result in medicine shortages.